
Sierra Club (USA): Bottled Water Facts
For the full policy on water, privatization and commodification,
go to
www.sierraclub.org/policy/conservation/commodification.asp
Water is a public resource, not a commodity. Public policy must
ensure the sustainability of safe water supplies for the benefit
of all people and the natural environment.
All water resources, including the oceans, must be protected as
a public trust so that commercial use of water does not diminish
public or ecological benefits.
Access to clean, sufficient, and affordable drinking water is a
human right necessary for human health and survival. This right
must be protected by government policies and international agencies,
consistent with ensuring access to safe and adequate quantities
of water resources for all wildlife on the planet and sustainability
of these resources.
Although bottled water may be needed in emergencies such as when
local drinking water is contaminated, the bottled water industry,
led by Nestlé,Coca Cola, and Pepsi Cola, is aggressively
promoting non-essential uses of bottled water. The withdrawal of
large quantities of water from springs and aquifers for bottling
has depleted household wells in rural areas, damaged wetlands, and
degraded aquifers. In the United States alone, more than 10 billion
plastic water bottles end up as garbage or litter each year.
IMPACTS TO ECOSYSTEMS AND WATER RESOURCES
Unnecessary consumption of drinking water in plastic bottles is
wasteful and damaging to the environment.
Waste: Millions of plastic bottles are not recycled and end up
in landfills, in parks and along roadways. Nine out of ten plastic
water bottles end up as garbage or litter.
That’s 30 million discarded plastic bottles each day—
more than 10 billion a year. Large amounts of energy is consumed
in manufacture, transportation, and recycling of the bottles.
Toxicity: In 2002, 1.5 million tons of plastic was used to package
6 billion gallons of bottled water. The production of this plastic
leads to the release of a variety of chemicals.
Most smaller bottles are made from polyethylene terephthalate (PET)
which, according to the Berkeley Ecology Center, generates more
than 100 times more toxic emissions than an equivalent amount of
glass. Leaching of chemicals into the water is also a concern.
“Eight of the ten 5-gallon polycarbonate jugs we checked
left residues of the endocrine disrupter, bisphenol A, in the water”
(Consumer Reports 8/00).
More research is needed regarding leaching of harmful chemicals
from all types of plastic bottles. Leaching increases with heat,
raising concern about storage and transportation of the bottles.
No problems have been associated with refillable stainless steel
containers.
Bottled water is regulated by the Food and Drug Administration,
which has weaker regulations than the E PA regulations for tap water.
(“ What’s in that Bottle?” Consumer Reports 1/03.)
Bottled water sold within states is regulated only by state agencies.
NRDC tested more than 1,000 bottles of 103 brands of bottled water.
They found contamination exceeding allowable limits in at least
one sample from about one-third of the brands, including synthetic
organics, bacteria, and arsenic. (www.nrdc.org/water/drinking/bwbwinx.asp)
WATER QUALITY: AWASH IN PLASTIC BOTTLES
The bottled water industry promotes bottled water as a h e a l
t h y, trendy drink, without mentioning that it can cost 1,000 times
as much as tap wa t e r. The Sierra Club believes that all people
should have access to affordable, clean drinking water. This means
protecting water sources and funding for upgrading municipal systems
should be a national priority. If you are concerned about the quality
or taste of your tap wa t e r, it is much cheaper to install a water
filter on your tap to remove the pollutants than to depend on bottled
water.
COST OF BOTTLED WATER
Cost Comparison
Bottled water can cost 1,000 times more than tap water —so
much more it’s almost impossible to portray in a bar chart.
SOURCES:
Tap:$.0015/gallon average, American Water Works Association,2002
www.tawwa.org/story_of_water/html/costs.htm
Filtered:$.13/gallon average, www.waterfiltercomparisons.com
Bottled:$1.27/gallon average, Natural Resources Defense Council
(NRDC),
March 1999 www.nrdc.org/water/drinking/bw/bwinx.asp
tap water: $.0015/gallon
filtered water: $.13/gallon
$.25 $.50 $.75 $1.00 $1.25
bottled water: $1.27/gallon
GLOBAL CORPORATE THREAT
Having created a growing market for bottled water, transnational
corporations are exercising their power to get access to springs,
aquifers, and municipal water supplies to keep their profits flowing,
with little regard for the environmental impacts of large water
withdrawals. Nestlé has taken over many small, independent
companies, set up much larger operations at local springs, and is
aggressively pursuing new sites around the Unites States. Coke’s
Dasani and Pepsi’s Aquafina brands depend on cheap municipal
water in the United States. Coke’s bottled water operation
in India is embroiled in controversy, where a “ Boycott Coke”
campaign is underway.
WHAT YOU CAN DO TO HELP
- Avoid using bottled water unless absolutely necessary.
- Use reusable stainless steel containers and carry tap water
with you when traveling.
- At public events and at home, offer pitchers of water.
- Find out where bottled water sold in your stores comes from
and if the pumping is impacting the environment.
- Advocate for strict state and local groundwater laws to protect
aquifers and other water resources.
- Ensure that good quality tap water is available for everyone
in your community at an affordable price.
- Advocate for adequate funding and good public management of
municipal water systems.
- Research the quality of your public drinking water.
- Join with Sierra Club in protecting our rivers, streams, and
wetlands from pollution to assure high quality public water supplies.
To learn more and get involved in the Sierra Club’s bottled
water campaign, visit
www.sierraclub.org/cac/water
Top
of page
|